

“You can't escape your dreams.”
Budget
$10M
Still reeling from the sudden loss of her parents, Anna (Whitney Peak) leaves New York to live with her estranged grandmother May (S. Epatha Merkerson) in a quiet Florida town. Isolated and vulnerable, she finds brief solace in the company of two local teens, Shawn (Finn Bennett) and Julie. But when she becomes complicit in their unforgivable act of violence against a younger child, her grief spirals into terror. Anna crosses paths with Mr. Sandman—the twisted soul of a tormented child who haunts bullies' dreams and feasts on their eyeballs when they wake. Anna must right her wrong before becoming a victim of this gruesome curse .
Imagine a nightmare that doesn't end when you wake up... Colin Tilley's directorial debut, Eye for an Eye, opens with this terrifying premise. What if there was an entity that hunts bullies in their dreams and steals their eyeballs? And his name is 'Mr. Sandman'... Anna, played by Whitney Peak, is grappling with grief and loneliness when she stumbles into an unimaginable nightmare. One of the film's most striking features is Mr. Sandman's origin story, told through stop-motion animation—a sequence that feels both folkloric and chilling . Critics praise the film as 'visually stunning' with genuinely disturbing practical effects, though some note the plot may feel familiar to horror fans . With a 92% Rotten Tomatoes score and a #1 spot on HBO Max , this indie horror is a must-watch. Can Anna's belated conscience stop the curse, or will she become Mr. Sandman's next victim?
Sign in to write a review
Sign In